There is something about separation that turns everyone around you into a family law expert. Your best friend went through a divorce six years ago, so naturally she knows exactly how yours is going to play out. Your brother-in-law has a buddy who got absolutely screwed in court, and he's pretty sure the same thing is about to happen to you. Your coworker's cousin managed to keep her pension, so apparently that's an option. And your neighbour, who has never been married, has some very strong opinions about what you're entitled to.
Then there's Google. And Chat GPT. And the Facebook divorce groups, where complete strangers with questionable judgment and an impressive amount of confidence are more than happy to tell you exactly what you should do.
By the time you finally sit down with a lawyer, you've received so much free legal advice that you're practically ready to argue your own case. There's just one small problem. Most of it is wrong.
Or, perhaps more accurately, some of it might have been right for someone else, somewhere else, under an entirely different set of circumstances. Which doesn't make it particularly useful to you.
But My Friend Got Half of Everything
I cannot tell you how many times I've heard some variation of, "Well, my friend went through this, and her lawyer told her..." And maybe her lawyer did tell her that. Maybe it was excellent advice. For her. But your friend's separation is not your separation. Maybe she was married for twenty years and you lived together for three. Maybe she brought substantial property into the relationship. Maybe her husband owned a business. Maybe they lived in Alberta, where the legislation differs from Saskatchewan's. Maybe she settled for something that wasn't actually her legal entitlement because she just wanted the whole thing over with.
Or maybe, and I say this with love, your friend doesn't actually understand what happened in her own divorce. It happens more often than you might think. People tend to remember the outcome of their separation, not necessarily the legal reasoning that got them there. And when they retell the story, a few inconvenient details sometimes disappear along the way. Suddenly, "I agreed to let him keep the house because I got his pension" becomes "The wife always gets the house." No. No, she does not.
Don't Move Out! You'll Lose the House!
This one deserves a special place in the Divorce Advice Hall of Fame. Someone tells their spouse they want to separate, and within approximately seventeen minutes, a well-meaning relative has warned them that if they leave the family home, they'll lose their entitlement to it.So now we have two people who can barely stand to be in the same room refusing to leave the house because Aunt Linda said so.
In Saskatchewan, moving out of the family home does not, by itself, mean you give up your interest in the property. There may be very good reasons to remain in the home, particularly where children are involved or there are concerns about finances, possession, or establishing a new parenting arrangement. But those are decisions to make based on your actual circumstances, not because your neighbour's ex-husband apparently lost everything when he moved into his brother's basement. And for the love of all things , if there is family violence or a genuine safety concern, please do not stay in an unsafe situation because someone told you leaving would hurt your property claim.
You Need to Get 50/50 Parenting or You'll Pay Child Support
My favorite. The parenting advice that manages to turn children into a mathematical equation. Somewhere along the way, people became convinced that equal parenting time is both an automatic legal entitlement and a clever way to avoid paying child support. Neither is true.
Parenting arrangements are determined based on the best interests of the children. Not what is fair to the parents. Not who is angrier. Not who cheated. And certainly not who has the better spreadsheet showing exactly how many hours the children spend in each household. And equal parenting time does not automatically eliminate child support. Where both parents have at least 40 percent of parenting time, child support is assessed under different considerations, including their respective incomes, the increased costs of shared parenting, and the circumstances of the children.
I've seen people become so fixated on getting exactly half the parenting time that they lose sight of whether the proposed arrangement actually works for their children. Your kids are not a timeshare. And parenting is not a competition you win by collecting the most overnights.
Don't Give Them Anything. Make Them Fight for It.
This advice usually comes from someone who is very emotionally invested in your divorce and has absolutely no intention of contributing to your legal bill. “Don't agree to anything." “Make him take you to court." “She doesn't deserve a penny."
It's easy to be a hard-ass when you're spending someone else's money.
Here's what people don't always appreciate: every issue you fight about has a cost. Sometimes that cost is financial. Sometimes it's emotional. Sometimes it's the damage done to a co-parenting relationship you're going to need to maintain for the next decade or more. That doesn't mean you should roll over and agree to something unreasonable. Far from it. There are absolutely times when you need to stand your ground, and there are cases that require a judge to make a decision. But there's a difference between standing up for yourself and fighting simply because you're angry.
I've watched people spend thousands of dollars arguing over things worth a fraction of that amount. And while I appreciate the business, I'd much rather see that money stay in your bank account. You do not get bonus points for making your divorce as difficult as possible.
Your Ex Can't Do That!
Maybe they can't. But maybe they can.
This is another favourite of the amateur legal community. Your ex wants to sell something? “They can't do that!"
Your ex wants to take the kids on vacation? “They can't do that!"
Your ex has started dating? “They can't do that!"
Well, sometimes they can. Sometimes they can't. And sometimes the answer is a deeply unsatisfying "it depends."
Family law is full of nuance. What seems outrageously unfair may be perfectly legal. And what seems entirely reasonable to you may create some significant legal problems. The fact that your ex is behaving like an asshole does not automatically mean they're breaking the law. Believe me, if being an asshole were illegal, the courts would need significantly more judges.
And Then There's the Internet
I love the internet. I really do. You can learn to fix your dishwasher, book a vacation, and find a recipe for just about anything. But legal advice from strangers on the internet is a different beast.
I've seen online discussions where someone asks a relatively straightforward family law question and receives forty-seven responses, most of which contradict each other. Several are based on American law. At least one person is convinced that signing a birth certificate is some sort of elaborate government conspiracy. And inevitably, someone recommends hiding assets.
Please don't hide assets. Full and honest financial disclosure is a fundamental part of resolving family property and support issues. Trying to conceal money or property can seriously undermine your credibility, increase legal costs, and result in consequences far worse than simply disclosing the asset in the first place.
And stay off of Chat GPT. It is not going to give you reliable advise based on your circumstances and the 15 page strategy brief if prepares will NOT be helpful to your lawyer.
If you're going to spend time researching your legal situation online, start with reliable Canadian sources and pay attention to which province's law you're reading. And remember that even accurate general information isn't a substitute for advice about your specific circumstances.
So Should You Ignore Everyone?
Of course not.
Your friends and family can be an incredible source of support during separation. They can listen while you vent, remind you to eat something other than toast, take you out for a drink, and tell you when you've been staring at your ex's social media for entirely too long. They can remind you that you're going to be okay. What they shouldn't be doing is directing your legal strategy.
There's a difference between emotional support and legal advice, and confusing the two can become very expensive. When someone tells you what you have to do in your separation, ask yourself a few questions. Do they actually understand the law in your province? Do they know the relevant facts of your situation? Do they understand the possible consequences of the advice they're giving you? And, perhaps most importantly, are they going to pay your legal bill if their brilliant strategy goes sideways?
I'm guessing not.
The Bottom Line
Separation is hard enough without trying to navigate everyone else's opinions about how you should handle it. Listen to your friends. Lean on your family. Accept the support of people who care about you. But when it comes to your legal rights, obligations, and strategy, get advice from someone who actually knows the law and understands your circumstances. Your best friend's divorce might make for a great story over wine. It is not a legal precedent.
And Aunt Linda, bless her heart, is not your lawyer.